TREE PAYOFF DISTRIBUTION FUNDAMENTALS
What a terminal payoff distribution preserves
- Probability mass function
- A discrete model assigns probability to specific terminal payoff values rather than to every point on a continuous curve.
- Expected payoff
- The probability-weighted average over repeated comparable decisions, not the payoff most likely to occur once.
- Dispersion
- Standard deviation measures overall payoff spread around the mean and includes both upside and downside deviations.
- Loss probability
- The total mass of leaves with payoff below zero; its magnitude is separate from how large those losses are.
- Discrete quantile
- The smallest payoff whose cumulative probability reaches a chosen percentile; ties and jumps are inherent, not rounding errors.
MODEL AND FORMULA
Why leaf-level probability mass is the distribution
TECHNICAL LANGUAGE
Discrete payoff distribution terms
- Payoff
- The signed consequence assigned to a terminal path on a single declared value basis.
- Expected-value contribution
- A leaf's payoff multiplied by its path probability.
- Probability mass
- The share of total probability assigned to one discrete outcome.
- Cumulative probability
- The sum of mass at or below a payoff after outcomes are sorted.
- Discrete percentile
- A payoff selected at the first cumulative-probability crossing of a percentile threshold.
- Downside mass
- The combined probability assigned to negative-payoff outcomes.
EVIDENCE AND DATA LINEAGE
Document probabilities and payoffs as separate evidence streams
Keep branch counts or elicitation records, conditional-outcome evidence, payoff worksheets, valuation date, discounting convention, currency, time horizon, and the rule for classifying negative outcomes. Verify that probabilities sum through the tree and that payoffs include comparable cost and benefit categories. Record expert dependencies when probabilities or consequences come from the same judgment source.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Questions about tree payoff distributions
Why can the median equal a leaf payoff with less than 50% individual probability?
The median depends on cumulative probability after sorting payoffs. Several lower-payoff leaves can combine so that the cumulative mass first reaches 50% at that leaf.
Does a positive expected value mean the option is safe?
No. Expected value can be positive while loss probability or worst-case consequence remains unacceptable. Review downside measures and decision constraints separately.
Why does the table retain success and failure labels if payoffs drive the distribution?
The labels preserve the event-tree meaning. A "success" leaf can still have a poor payoff under some value definitions, so payoff classification is calculated independently from the outcome label.
Can I compare standard deviations across different currencies or horizons?
Not directly. Convert to a common valuation basis, price date, horizon, and risk convention before comparison.
Why do percentile results jump when I adjust a probability slightly?
A discrete CDF advances by entire leaf masses. Crossing a percentile threshold transfers the quantile to another terminal payoff rather than moving it continuously.
When is simulation preferable?
Simulation becomes useful with many branches, dependent variables, continuous payoff distributions, or repeated stages. For four fixed leaves, exact enumeration is clearer and free of simulation error.
IMPORTANT NOTE
A complete ledger is still only as complete as the tree
The calculations exactly summarize the entered four-leaf distribution. They do not prove that all material pathways are represented, that probabilities are calibrated, or that signed payoffs capture legal, safety, strategic, liquidity, or human consequences.